FIRE PIT
HOT TUB
Downtown Lake Geneva
Captain Cook
4 BD · 2 BA · SLEEPS 9
ELITE HOMES•ELITE EXPERIENCES
Find Your Elite Lake Rental
FEATURED RENTALS
Our Most Loved Retreats
Hand-picked by our team. Booked by guests who keep coming back.
NEWFIRE PIT
Lauderdale Lakes
Lauderdale Lookout
4 BD · 3 BA · SLEEPS 10
LAKEFRONT
POOL
Lake Geneva
Glass Vista
2 BD · 2 BA · SLEEPS 6
NEWGOLF CART
FIRE PIT
Lake Geneva
Linn Lodge
3 BD · 2 BA · SLEEPS 10
NEWDOG FRIENDLY
FIRE PIT
Williams Bay
Sunny Bay
3 BD · 1 BA · SLEEPS 6
FIRE PIT
Lake Geneva
Black Point House
4 BD · 2 BA · SLEEPS 10
NEWFIRE PIT
WALK TO DOWNTOWN
Downtown Lake Geneva
Four Gables Manor and Coach House
5 BD · 3.5 BA · SLEEPS 10
GOLF CART
DOG FRIENDLY
Lake Geneva
Como Cabana
3 BD · 2 BA · SLEEPS 6
NEWWALK TO DOWNTOWN
Downtown Lake Geneva
The Mystic Inn
3 BD · 1 BA · SLEEPS 6
NEWFIRE PIT
GAME ROOM
Lake Geneva
Pickle My Fancy
5 BD · 3.5 BA · SLEEPS 12
NEWWALK TO DOWNTOWN
FIRE PIT
Downtown Lake Geneva
Clover The Top
3 BD · 1 BA · SLEEPS 6
NEWFIRE PIT
Lake Geneva
The Lake Shore Legacy
4 BD · 2 BA · SLEEPS 8
POOL
DOG FRIENDLY
Lake Geneva
Geneva Grove
4 BD · 2 BA · SLEEPS 8
FIRE PIT
LAKEFRONT
Delavan Lake
Shanahan Shores
3 BD · 2 BA · SLEEPS 8
FIRE PIT
WALK TO DOWNTOWN
Downtown Lake Geneva
The Darwin
4 BD · 2 BA · SLEEPS 10
FIRE PIT
WALK TO DOWNTOWN
Downtown Lake Geneva
The Cottage on Warren
3 BD · 2 BA · SLEEPS 8
LAKEFRONT
Powers Lake
Lake Daze
5 BD · 2 BA · SLEEPS 11
FIRE PIT
GAME ROOM
Downtown Lake Geneva
Heeler House
3 BD · 2.5 BA · SLEEPS 8
Discover
Browse by Experience
JUST ADDED
Newly Added Properties
Fresh additions to our curated collection.
NEWDOG FRIENDLY
FIRE PIT
Williams Bay
Sunny Bay
3 BD · 1 BA · SLEEPS 6
NEWFIRE PIT
Lauderdale Lakes
Lauderdale Lookout
4 BD · 3 BA · SLEEPS 10
NEWFIRE PIT
Lake Geneva
The Lake Shore Legacy
4 BD · 2 BA · SLEEPS 8
NEWWALK TO DOWNTOWN
FIRE PIT
Downtown Lake Geneva
Clover The Top
3 BD · 1 BA · SLEEPS 6
NEWGOLF CART
FIRE PIT
Lake Geneva
Linn Lodge
3 BD · 2 BA · SLEEPS 10
NEWFIRE PIT
GAME ROOM
Lake Geneva
Pickle My Fancy
5 BD · 3.5 BA · SLEEPS 12
NEWFIRE PIT
WALK TO DOWNTOWN
Downtown Lake Geneva
Four Gables Manor and Coach House
5 BD · 3.5 BA · SLEEPS 10
NEWWALK TO DOWNTOWN
Downtown Lake Geneva
The Mystic Inn
3 BD · 1 BA · SLEEPS 6
Elite Lake Rentals is the Lake Geneva Area's curated vacation home collection. From the historic shores of Geneva Lake to the quieter waters of Lake Como, Delavan Lake, Lauderdale Lakes, and Powers Lake, our handpicked homes are modern, well-maintained, and locally managed by people who actually live here.
Why Elite Lake Rentals
The Elite Difference
Transparent pricing, local ownership, and personal care that puts your stay first.
Best Rates Guaranteed
Book direct with Elite Lake Rentals and skip the OTA fees that inflate every booking on Vrbo and Airbnb. The price you see is the price you pay. No surprise service charges at checkout. No marked-up cleaning fees. Just transparent, all-in pricing on every home in our collection.
Locally Owned & Operated
We live here. Elite Lake Rentals is family-owned and based right in the Lake Geneva Area. When you need us, our team is minutes away. Not a call center in another time zone. Not an offshore agent reading a script. Real people, real local knowledge, real accountability for every stay.
Elite Property Care
Your home isn't lost in an overwhelming rental pool. We're a boutique management company, highly selective in the homes we represent. Every property in our collection gets the personal attention that protects your investment and earns guest loyalty.
Welcome
Lake Geneva Area's Curated Collection
Thousands of vacationers visit the Lake Geneva Area every year for its top-rated lakes, charming downtowns, and world-class dining. Whether you're planning a romantic weekend, a multi-generational family gathering, or a getaway with friends, our handpicked collection of vacation homes provides the perfect home base. Locally owned, professionally managed, and personally maintained; we treat your stay like our own.
Our Portfolio
A Home for Every Stay
From cozy lakefront cottages to spacious estates with room for extended families, our portfolio is built for every kind of getaway. Walking distance to downtown Lake Geneva. Direct access to Geneva Lake. Quiet retreats on Lake Como, Delavan Lake, Lauderdale Lakes, and Powers Lake. Browse our full collection to find the perfect match for your group.
Plan Ahead
Looking for a Holiday Getaway?
Pre-selected dates for our most popular weekends. Book early — they sell out fast.
Explore
Beyond the Front Door
What Guests Say
Trusted by guests across every platform
Reviews from Google, Airbnb, VRBO, and more — the same reviews other guests use to decide.
4.9★ average · 430+ verified guest reviews
I love this place it’s amazing , definitely coming back if possible
Eliezer C. · Sep 2026
Oh we loved this house! It was beautifully appointed and very clean. The location was perfect for trips into town.The backyard was truly fantastic. We enjoyed dining outdoors and sitting around the fire pit every evening. An additional bonus was the fantastic playground in the elementary school nest door.
Jean L. · Sep 2026
Place was awesome! It’s everything you see in the pictures. Great place for a group of guys to have an awesome weekend, especially if you want to run some basketball / pickleball!
Michael · Sep 2026
For Homeowners
Maximize Your Investment. Minimize Your Stress.
Partnering with Elite Lake Rentals means more than just bookings. We treat your home as if it were our own, delivering exceptional guest experiences while protecting and enhancing your investment in the Lake Geneva Area.
- Professional photography and marketing
- Dynamic pricing optimization
- 24/7 guest support and communication
- Meticulous property care and maintenance
- Detailed owner reporting and transparency
Free Rental Evaluation
Discover Your Property's True Potential
Follow Along
From Our Lake Geneva Lens
Real moments from our properties, our guests, and our community.
Stay Connected
Exclusive offers and new property alerts from across the Lake Geneva Area, delivered to your inbox.
