Elite Lake Rentals

Elite Lake Rentals Vacation Rental Management

Elite Lake Rentals is a boutique property management company, locally owned and operated by Susan Smolarek and her son Jason. Susan has called Walworth County home since 2006 and Jason headed for the warm weather of Florida after graduating from UW-Stout in 2008. We believe our hands on, owner managed philosophy is the best fit with our customers. Bigger isn’t always better. Want to talk to the owner of your property management company? Just give us a call…To us, you’re not just an address or unit number, you’re part of the Elite Lake Rentals Family.


Elite Lake Rentals is a full-service vacation rental management company specializing in newly renovated and modern lake homes, cottages, and condos on or near the lake. We only represent top-quality homes and partner with like-minded homeowners who understand the importance of a well-maintained and furnished property. Discover what makes Elite unique among vacation rental management companies.

Family owned and operated

Elite was founded in Lake Geneva, and our entire team is based here. We are local area experts and provide insider tips to maximize the guest experience.

Centrally Located

The Elite home base is located in the heart of Walworth County just minutes from our vacation homes, and we can respond to any issue in a moment’s notice.

Rental Policy Enforcement

In addition to rigorously screening guests, we strictly enforce our Good Neighbor agreement and rental policies to prevent problems before they happen.

Distinguished Reputation

Elite enjoys an excellent reputation both online and offline. We have built our reputation in Lake Geneva by consistently exceeding guest and homeowner expectations.


Our team of experts is integral to the success of Elite. We are trained specialists in property care, homeowner services, guest services, and sales and marketing. As a homeowner-partner, you’ll enjoy a full range of vacation rental management services, maximum rental revenue, and the peace of mind that your home is receiving the highest level of care.

Elite Property Care

Boutique Level Service

Our goal is not to be the largest management company in the area, our goal is to provide the best guest and homeowner experience and manage the best properties.

Local Preferred Vendors

Routine maintenance is scheduled, and repairs are made by skilled technicians when work is required. We will not nickel and dime you and never include markups on invoices.

Quality Assurance and Safety Inspections

We don’t rely on housekeepers to report problems. We personally inspect all homes before and after each guest stay to ensure our vacation rentals are kept in top condition and any potential issues are identified.

Professional Housekeeping

Well-trained housekeepers clean our rental homes before every reservation and we complete inspections after every departure. In addition, daily housekeeping services are made available to guests and all linens are professionally laundered offsite.

Learn about the Elite experience and compare our vacation rental services to your current provider – email owners@elitelakerentals.com or call 262-228-4466